Skip to main content

Siddhant versus State – A fight for disabled students (Court)

Siddhant versus State – A fight for disabled students

Aurangabad, March 9, 2018: The Central Board of Secondary Education (CBSE) has refrained from striking down the circular dated 17/10/2017 except for Siddhant. The circular will not affect rights of the disabled child and he can appear for exams for the subjects he opted in standard 9 unlike other students who have to appear for the exams as per the circular issued by the CBSE board which includes change in the curriculum.

Siddhant Manudhane suffering from dyslexia, dysgraphia and dyscalculic, disability in reading, writing and understanding arithmetic which is learning disability. Student of standard 10 at Kashinath Palod Public School at Jalgaon that is affiliated to CBSE board under the control of Union of India. The regional office of CBSE is at Chennai and the main board is at Prit Vihar, Delhi.

According to Writ Petition No. 1744 of 2005, with a mutual agreement between the State Government Educational and Authorities and all schools agreed to a scheme as per annexure 10 for giving exemtions, concessions and special facilities to the students with learning disability. There is no dispute that CBSE has accepted the policy and has issued general instructions for giving exemptions, concessions and facilities like extended time limit or services of scribe at the time of examinations. The students suffering from learning disability were exempted from taking a subject of third language. They were supposed to study only one compulsory language as against two. Besides, they were supposed to opt for four, as against five for others.

On 17/10/2017 CBSC Board office, Delhi issued circular to all the institutes according to which the subject No.s. 461 to 467 were discontinued (Siddhant’s subject no. 462-IT was amongst them). The students were given option to choose the subjects having code NO.s. 401 to 407 in place of their earlier subjects from 461 to 467. The circular also provided select groups of subjects divided into five categories for examination of standard 10th, according to which, out of subjects having code nos. 165 and 166, only one can be chosen and subject no. 462 introduced as 402.

Now, Siddhant had problem of choosing a totally new subject as an alternative for subject having code no. 165 or 166, and also to select one more subject in place of subject 462. According to the circular, the common option of subjects should be as per list of valid combinations. The schools were directed to complete the registration process through on-line entry option only and list of candidates submitted online could be corrected by submission of hard copy. Siddhant had approached the school and put forth his difficulty in selecting new subjects and then appearing for SCC exam with new subjects within a short time. It was a rule that the school was bound to submit list of all the candidates and even in case of single failure to register the entry, it would result in the non-registration of the school. The principal of the school wrote a letter to the CBSE regional office but there was no communication. In order, to avoid inconvenience to other students, Siddhant chose the following two subjects. ‘Painting-49 in place of IT-462’ and ‘Home science in place of Information and Communication Technology-166’.

The learned counsel Siddhant (petitioner) Mrs. Rashmi Kulkarni said that the circular dated 17/10/2017 is contrary to the rules of CBSE that 9th and 10th standard are integrated courses. She also put up the argument that even for ordinary students, it is very difficult to change the subjects in midst of the year when the new subjects are totally unknown to them. In Siddhant’s case, he is suffering from learning disability and his parents have tried hard to teach the subjects to him. He had become familiar with the subjects selected by him for 9th standard examination. It will be practically impossible for him to prepare himself for the new subjects.

Therefore, the circular dated 17/10/2017 should be quashed and Siddhant should be permitted to select the subjects for which he had appeared In the 9th standard exam.

Summary of the Case:
Siddhant filed a petition seeking quashing of circular dated 17/10/2017, to refrain the Board from changing curriculum in the midst of academic year of 10th standard students in view of the integrated course of 9th and 10th year course, to accept the correct final registration slip dated 17/11/2017 of the petitioner submitted by principal for class 10th examination in March-2018, respondents to allow the petitioner to appear for 10th standard examination with subjects chosen for by him for 9th standard examination and other interim reliefs.

“The Board said that the CBSE exams are held throughout India and since they are considering the case of Siddhant only, who is differently abled and for which he had special exemptions, concessions and facilities. The Board has refrained from striking down the circular dated 17/10/2017, except for Siddhant. The circular dated 17/10/2017 will not affect the rights of Siddhant. The rule is made absolute all terms. Parties to act upon authenticated copy of this order.”


Popular posts from this blog

An Interview with Colonel

Teaching and Guidance acts as an important part or we can say is an important aspect of life. It is something which never ends i.e. no matter of what age you are or where you are, teaching and guidance can be done in any manner with anyone. Many people have told the importance of it in their own means. Similarly, L. Colonel Dr. Satish Dhage, Director of MGM Institute of Competitive Examinations (ICE) have said the importance and explained it. Dr. Dhage have served as an officer in Indian army and at present are the director of MGM ICE as well as a lecturer in the same.
Q. What role does teaching and guidance play in your life based on your experience from a medico-army officer to the Director of M.G.M ICE?
A. "In reality, teacher’s role is the most important role, because as far as talent is concerned, every person is talented. I believe that there is 100% energy in every person and if you want to be successful, what requires is a proper direction. I believe that there are 3 D’s wh…


Aurangabad, August 5, 2017: Theft cases amounting Rs.126.42 lakh were registered from April-2017 to June-2017 which is one of the major issue for the city. According to the official report only Rs.6.95 lakh were assessed and FIRs were filed against the rest of them in the concerned police stations. According to the govt. as for the household consumption, 2kW is permitted and for the commercial consumption, 20kW is permitted. If broken the law, charges are imposed according to ‘Electricity Act 2003’. Under this act, two sections are assigned for the theft of electricity; Section 126 and Section 135. Under section 126, stealing electricity of neighbours and using the provided electricity for other purposes than the permitted ones are covered. Section 135 includes theft of electricity using hooks on service wires, bypassing meter wire, using remotes to stop the transfer of electric current to the specified location, breaking of shield of m…

Human Rights

“We don’t know what the ‘Right to an Adequate Standard of Living’ is.” Say Labourers
Aurangabad, August 19, 2017: Labourers “today” earn at most eight thousand rupees a month and are still waiting for government to take an action in favour of them. Right to an adequate standard of living is being violated in almost all the parts of the city and no one is ready to take the responsibility for it.
Right to an adequate standard of living is one of the fundamental rights declared by the UN which is right of every human being irrespective of the place, sex, caste, creed and economic background. As a fundamental right no one can snatch it from the person, if he/she is being deprived of it. Adequate standard of living is considered to be fulfilled if the person is having the basic needs on a regular basis and is living his/her life with all the basic requirements along with the needs. Today, this right is being violated in almost each and every part of the city. Labourers especially get affecte…